This MLB tactical audit highlights value in the Cincinnati Reds given their superior recent form (4W-1L) and a decisive 7-2 head-to-head victory against the struggling New York Mets (1W-4L). Market signals show a clear lean towards lower team totals, suggesting a pitching-dominant or low-scoring affair. Our model identifies a sustainable pricing discrepancy on the Reds Moneyline and Under 7.5 total runs, aligning with observed performance trends and market sentiment, while also finding value in the Reds -1.5 spread.